As athletes continue to get bigger, faster, and stronger, each sport has also picked up the speed. Reaction time and agility are two essentials for athletes and it is clear to me that catchers in baseball and softball along with goaltenders (or keepers) in hockey and soccer are the players that must have more quickness and agility than any other player on the field or court. In today's world, it seems as if these positions rarely receive the recognition they deserve. Take a no-hitter or perfect game for instance, the catcher calls the pitches, picks the location, and is responsible for nearly every move the pitcher makes other than the actual pitch. Half the battle is knowing what pitch to throw and where to put it when facing a minimum of 27 hitters. Yet the catcher rarely receives any sort of credit for the history-making feat. With this in mind, here is a closer look into just how tough playing these positions is and which of these positions is the toughest to play.
|
Yadier Molina of the St. Louis Cardinals |
Catcher: For the majority of my baseball career I played catcher and was able to catch quite a few good pitchers. Being in the mindset of a catcher also made me appreciate pitchers even when I was hitting. You start to figure out different pitch calls and spots that the opposing catcher may be calling. It truly is an art and something that takes alot of work and attention to detail.
With that being said, the fastest pitcher I ever faced in high school was clocked at 91 mph. When seeing a 90 mph fastball, the pitch generally hits the glove in .21 seconds. It takes about .1 seconds to blink, so if you blink while that pitch is coming you might as well give up and move out of the way. Let's go over this now: you have .21 seconds till that ball hits your glove if you're a catcher. What if that fastball is low and away and in the dirt? You have .21 seconds to slide over, drop to your knees, get your glove in between your legs, and hunch your shoulders forward. That's four things you have to do in .21 seconds before you can even think about stopping the actual pitch from hitting the backstop.
That is where foot work comes in. Catchers have to be quick and on their toes because if you're sitting back on your heels while you're in a squat you're a sitting duck. Not to mention the flexibility that goes into a catcher's hip-flexors that enables them to slide over in that .21 seconds. Guys like Yadier Molina make catching look so easy, but given these numbers it can really make any fan appreciate how hard he has worked to be, what I believe, the best catcher in the MLB.
|
Martin Brodeur of the New Jersey Devils |
Goaltender (Hockey): Hockey is a sport that I have never played and have only recently gotten into watching. After noticing the speed that is behind a puck off a player's stick, I have quite an appreciation for a goaltender's reaction time.
With a goal that is only four feet tall and six feet wide, one might think being a goaltender is not as hard as people think simply because of these three sports we are referring to, hockey goaltenders have the smallest amount of space to defend. A hockey puck and baseball differ in diameter by merely fractions of an inch (a puck is 3" and a baseball is 2.9"), so the argument is already somewhat similar. Throw in the fact that most hockey shots are clocked between 90 mph and 100 mph and the goaltenders have alot in common with catchers.
The key factor in this debate, however, is where the puck or ball is coming from. In baseball, it's just the catcher and the hitter with only a hitter in between on one side of the plate. In hockey, bodies are flying and the shot is coming from the ground. A pitch in baseball is coming from 60.6 feet away and the reaction time is .21 seconds as I discussed earlier. Now imagine that a hockey puck traveling at the exact same speed is coming from the same distance of, generously, 60 feet. The reaction time from when the puck leaves the stick to when it reaches the goal line is up from .21 seconds to about 1.17 seconds. Believe it or not, that is a huge difference in time. Yet when you throw in that you probably have three or four bodies between you and the player ripping the shot, your vision is nothing short of limited. Yes you have more time, but picking up on that puck is going to be a crazy task. And, much like baseball, the flexibility needed to make the jaw-dropping saves is something to behold. Being on skates and trying to move as quickly as required is an art of it's own.
|
Tim Howard of Team USA |
Keeper (Soccer): Being a collegiate-level goalie (or keeper, whatever suits you), I have had the privelage and blessing to play with, and face, numerous talented players. I have seen some of the craziest shots that, to the credit of whoever took the shot, are virtually unstoppable. Just like baseball and hockey, as you grow older the speed and placement of shots continues to improve.
A soccer goal stands 8 feet tall and 24 feet wide which is quite a large amount of space compared to soccer or hockey. There isn't a specific reaction time that can be referred to due to the fact that a shot in soccer could come for numerous spots on the field with different spin on the ball and at different angles. Alot goes into defending a shot and perhaps the toughest situation, other than a penalty kick of course, is a free kick from just outside the box. If the ball is placed in the middle at the top of the box, most goalies would place five defenders in the wall. Those five cover, say, the right side of your goal and it is your responsibility to cover, or at least position yourself, on the left side of your goal. The shot is coming from about twenty yards out and could reach a maximum of about 60 mph.
So once again, you have 60 feet of space in front of you but a considerably slower pace behind the ball. Factor in that you have 24 feet of total width to cover in that small window of time, not to mention that you have to read the shot as it comes over the wall, and you have alot of work to do in very little time. Being a goalie is tough, but in a different sense than being a catcher or goaltender in hockey.
These three sports are the three biggest sports in the world and they have presented us with phenomenal athletes from multiple countries. These sports will never fail to be appreciated but today I wanted to shed light on what I believe are the toughest positions to play in these three sports. While I grew up playing baseball and soccer, after reading thinking about being a goaltender in hockey I believe that it would have to be the toughest of the three. The game is the fastest-paced of the three and your focus as a goaltender is at a higher demand than a catcher or goalie. It's a tough call to make, but ultimately I believe that hockey presents the hardest job.